Clinicians and researchers discuss the questions behind behavioural care. Watch excerpts from our first roundtable, on challenging behaviour following acquired brain injury.
From the discussion
Reported as challenging on the ward. What the panel said it turned out to be: pain (Andrew Worthington), the lights (Alistair Teager), distress (Sara da Silva Ramos), autism nobody had spotted (Alistair Teager).
Roundtable 1
Managing challenging behaviour following acquired brain injury
Four psychologists spent just over an hour discussing what counts as challenging behaviour after a brain injury, and how teams should respond to it.
One idea kept coming back. A behaviour labelled challenging can be a sign of something else, such as pain or a need the person can’t put into words.
Much of the discussion was about how to find out what.
The panel
Professor Nick Alderman
Clinical Neuropsychologist and Clinical Lead, Melo
ChairTurn over
Professor Andrew Worthington
Consultant Clinical Neuropsychologist. Co-editor, with Nick Alderman, of Managing Challenging Behaviour Following Acquired Brain Injury.
Turn over
Dr Sara da Silva Ramos
Research Psychologist, Brainkind
Turn over
Dr Alistair Teager
Consultant Clinical Neuropsychologist and clinical advisor to Melo
Turn over
Next roundtable
Take part in the next roundtable
We’re planning the next roundtable for early 2027 and want to widen the conversation. Leave your details and we’ll tell you when it’s confirmed. If there’s a question you’d like clinicians to discuss, let us know.
Our privacy notice explains how we look after your details.
What the panel kept coming back to
Whether a behaviour gets called challenging depends a lot on the people and the service around it. One team agreed on only one behaviour. Another found a quarter of its incident forms didn’t meet the definition.
Several panellists described behaviour that turned out to be a sign of something else, such as pain nobody had spotted or a ward too bright for someone with autism.
Staff have long treated behaviour forms as someone else’s job. The panel talked about what changes when staff can see what their recording is for.
More from the discussion
Showing all 6 clips
When the behaviour was pain
A patient described as challenging in physiotherapy turned out to have an undiagnosed condition that made moving extremely painful. Andrew Worthington on checking for medical causes first, and why sometimes the job is knowing when not to intervene.
When the challenge is doing too little
Some people with a brain injury do very little unless someone prompts them, even to eat or drink. Sara da Silva Ramos and Nick Alderman on why this can be as hard to manage as aggression, and what happens when that person goes home.
One behaviour everyone agreed on
Asked to rank the behaviours staff kept raising, one specialist team fully agreed on only one. Nick Alderman on what that says about who decides what counts as challenging.
“You’re not filling in these forms for me”
Why staff have long rolled their eyes at behaviour forms, and what might change that. Andrew Worthington and Sara da Silva Ramos on giving staff a stake in what they record.
Who decides what goes on the incident report?
Alistair Teager’s team checked five years of ABC charts, the forms staff complete after a behavioural incident, against a definition of challenging behaviour. A quarter didn’t meet it. Alistair and Nick Alderman on why anxiety and tearfulness were being recorded as challenging.
Challenging, or misunderstood?
Some patients arrive on acute wards with needs nobody has picked up, such as autism. Alistair Teager on how the ward itself can cause distress, and on seeing the person in “bay one, bed four”.




